Archive for February, 2008

Oh, I’m not in Kansas Anymore.

February 15th, 2008 by Claudia D'Arcy

I started blogging on a lark in late ’05 and have been pretty consistant with it since then. Granted I was writing before, but that was mostly on forums and I was always better with one on my long rants rather than a quicky supportive hug kind of thing.  The blog concept was just perfect for me…my own public soapbox…ahhh. But, I have to face the fact that I am a niche blogger. A small niche blogger..more a niche in a niche. And even if now, I am a well known respected Blogger, it is still in my tiny Adoption Blog niche. Not even the general “Adoption” blogs, as most of them are written by adoptive parents or wanna be adoptive parents who sign the glories of Adoption, but the contoversial and often ugly “Adoption Truth” bloggers where we expose the ugly side of it all. And while I know like *all* the big names in Adoption world…it’s a tiny world and unless you are somehow interested in Adoption Issues, you don’t know me.

The other side of this is that I have hardly paid any attention at all to Bloggers outside the Adoption Community. Of course, that all changed these last few weeks. Now it’s my job to know and wow, I have been living in a tiny little bubble! My eyes are opened and they smart from all this big city smog while my neck is cramped from looking at these huge tall buildings….Lordy, the Blogosphere is much huger than I thought, but still somehow, just through the nature of blogging, I feel like I know some of the big dogs already.

I don’t necessarily “get” all the big deals in the blogosphere.  The whole gadet thing alludes me, but then again, I am a girl..hence no special tool..so the grown up toy..aka gaget.. thing leaves me flat. Of course I cannot use my gentle sex as an excuse, as the gossip/Holloywood blogs are sleepers to me as well, I don’t get the cute cat giggkes and I have been confused by the knitting craze for years new. Knitters obviously cross many borders as Wooly Bloggers have been duel idenified as Adoption Bloggers a long time ago now.  Then again, I get all wrapped up sometimes with visions of grand uniqueness…a hold over I fear from being a “special” birth mother… so I want to think that I am just *too cool* to get interested in what the *typical* American blog reader likes. In any case, I better get over myself real quick!

On the upside, I have really been learning all kinds of new things this week besides finding out who the Kings of Blog World are. There is even a colorized map of it! Who knew! And Adoption Blogs are NOT mentioned at all….sniff sniff.

So I am feeling ready to get out from behind my little snow globe and say hi to everyone else. So while I do feel like the small town girl in a huge big city, I am not afraid of getting mugged. Heck, I have never been mugged for real and that even was true when I was a little 17 year old chickie running around Mannhatten. Plus that’s one thing good about growing up in Adoption land……there ain’t nobody who is gonna get under my thick skin.

Ethical Considerations

February 15th, 2008 by Claudia D'Arcy

I love this post and I love the comment conversation.

Why?   I have been doing little more in the past fortnight aside from reading blogs about how to make money from blogs and what bloggers think about making money from blogs.  And this is a wonderful conversation about all the things that Blogg.io is about and it is looking for answers to the really important ethical questions.  Mark Collier brings it all home with the one question:  What does the blog reader get from a Blogger receiving compensation from advertisements and other incomes generated from a blogger’s ability to blog?  He then goes on to give examples of how it could work and what might not work and, as I said, the comments keep the discussion going.

Now I almost have an ethical dilemma as I have a job to go to blogs and promote Blogg.io and I have to do that through commentary at times.  Now as a blogger, I can’t stand when my blog would get spammed about some stupid money making thing that had NO relevance to my blog. At first I would look up the stupid spammers website and send back my own version of adoption “spam” just to return the favor, but eventually, I enabled my capcha thingy, as annoying as it is, to get rid of the spam content.

Given that I AM going to blog posts where conversations are about monetization of blogs and Blogg.io is a way to monetize one’s blogs, so it’s not like I am popping in on a knitter and talking about cats, or adoption blog faux pas, going to a PAP blog and calling them baby stealers (and if you have no idea what that means, then don’t worry about it, or go to my personal blog and learn..lol) But still, sometimes I feel just a little dirty. It is my job. I am getting paid. I am now straddling the line between blogger and marketer. I am blogging, but I am marketing. I could be seen as spamming, or at least pitching, (which I have been called out on) and I don’t like that.

It’s the ethics that save me.

Which brings me back to Mack’s piece and his question about the benefits of the reader.  See, with the whole premise of Blogg.io to be a mechanism connecting Bloggers to marketers it only makes sense if the bloggers get what they want out of it. No, let me correct that. It will only work if the bloggers get what they want out of it. They can’t get crap. It can’t be spam.  It can’t be more work.  Granted the money might be helpful in some degree, but unless you are being hit with a new communiqué every day, then participating in Blogg.io is not going to really pay the rent.  Even if you and targeted for a Blogger exclusive, that’s still not a rent payment unless you share a rusty trailer in a shanty town. And I’m not dissing my employers with this; it’s just the cost of living in the world.

What Blogg.io IS giving to the Bloggers is credibility, even if they, we, have claimed credibility already on our own.  There is recognition, as a whole, for bloggers as a force. Yeah us and I mean us, the Blogger us.

Now, with the ideal premise of Blogg.io, there is something in it for the marketers and PR folks if they get the opportunity to harness that Blogger force, and get their information releases though quality means into the Blogosphere. That’s easy and we might be able to put a money value on it. Oh right, my boss guys did already…it’s the cost of the products Blogg.io offers. Ha-ha.

So back to Mack’s question if applied here: What does the reader get out of a Blogger who has joined Blogg.io?

The readers get improved content. 

The content is improved because the blogger has the OPPORTUNITY to write about relevant information that might not have been available to them. Notice my capitalization emphasis…the key word here is OPPORTUNITY. The blogger is not OBLIGATED to post about the marketers content to be paid, they are given the choice. What they are getting paid for is their TIME to review the information, usually a press release, which has been proven to be RELEVANT to what they CHOOSE to blog about.  Paid to read the blogger is, not paid to write. That was my bad Yoda speak, but like Yoda, it’s all about not going to the dark side.

Oh, granted it might be about one’s “point of view” if I want to keep running with my Star Wars obsession, but I don’t feel like I am rationalizing.  Yes, I comment on the originally post, and the link back on my name will take you to my job site, but I didn’t spam. I didn’t.  I commented… teaser comment really…with nothing by name…just this lovely track back. J After all, it is my job.

New Glass Ceilings

February 15th, 2008 by Claudia D'Arcy

Since I have started this journey out of the safety of the adoption Blog world, I have noticed something very interesting. I have this job at Blogg.io. Which is really excellent as I was actually qualified for this job because I blogged.  Blogg.io has forced me to get out of my comfort zone and see the big picture.

So now I pay attention to ratings and SEO and my job is, to a degree, to find the key Bloggers and relate to them on their levels. After all, blogging is about building relationships so if I need to know and really to care about what the top bloggers are writing about.  Currently, I am running all over the web reading about this whole new world, about PR and marketing, monetizing blogs, and ad sense, and wow…I have to say it is pretty damn interesting.

Ok, enough preamble.  Here’s what has really stuck with me in the past few days: there is a gender difference in the Blogosphere. The official top blogs according to Technorati are consistently Engadget, GizmodoTechcrunchBoing BoingLifehackerArsTechnicaProBlogger, and the Huffington Post.  They win, hands down over and over again. There are a few more, but really, the ONLY two of these that are associated with women is the Huffington Post’s Arianna Huffington and the editor of Lifehacker, Gina Trapani, and there are writers of both sex on those and they write about politics and news and technical stuff and I am not saying that to discredit it, but to make my point.

The top blogs are about technology, gadgets, business, news, politics, and how to make money from blogs or marketing. The only things “soft” that make it to the top lists? Hollywood gossip and “cute” things like IcanhasCheezburger.  While they might be amusing and have subscribers, really, they are not going to change the way people think about the world.  Plus, these are not the blogs that are making money.

They guys that do make money off their blogs? They are the ones who are talking about making money off their blogs and I find myself, a female blogger who has a niche blog with not ONE ad on it, totally out on my own.  I am supposed to talk about how to make money from a blog and I don’t.  I mean, I can NOW begin to write about it because all I have been doing in the past three weeks is reading about marketing one’s blog, gaining subscribers, generating ad revenue, but I don’t do any of this by practice..and really NO OTHER WOMEN SEEM TO WITH GREAT SUCCESS.

Oh wait… there is Dooce who ranks #58 and apparently supports a family of three according to Heather’s “about” page. But the blogs that consistently make it to the top are either exclusively made up of men, or write about “men’s things”.

Let’s take a look at this shall we?

Blogging has been deemed, by more than one, to be about “building relationships”.

Business, marketing, public relations, search engine optimization, gadgets, making money, politics, news, what Google, Microsoft or Yahoo are doing, etc. all gain high subscribers, all lend themselves to ads and reach top popularity.  And this is the stuff that seems to be exclusive to men for the most part. They call it relationships and all seem to refer to each other and be buds, but wow, I am sorry, it’s like a New Old boys’ network.

Women write about other things. We do knitting, or crafts, or DYIs, or the mommy blog, or the breast feeding blog, or the infertility blog, or like me, the adoption blog, or we are just snarky and write about all kinds of other things. And we do build these huge networks and relationships but…they really don’t make the big lists.

I mean even looking at Blogher, a social network made for women who do blog and the top articles on there today are: Horoscope, fresh herbs, the primaries, Yahoo vs., Facebook, Diet soda and Arthritis, another campaign article, TV and sexism and kids, eco scare films, buying books and friends keeping one grounded.  Now, granted three of the ten listed are about “hard issues”, politics and techno stuff, but they are on the Blogher blogs, not “out there”, so guess what? They don’t count! Not to be mean, but they are in their self created microcosm. Which means that, no matter how successful Blogher becomes, and no matter how many relationships are built, it is still a larger, isolated fishbowl.

I see it…I have participated in it…and yet I don’t get it.  It’s another glass ceiling, created in an place where there are no rules, and there should not be a ceiling. But it’s there and I want to break it.

Time Warp to 2005

February 13th, 2008 by Claudia D'Arcy

I love this job right now. I get into the office, and on a cold, wet, snowy icy day like today, it is absurdly quiet here as it seems half our office has not trekked in. I sit in my quiet corner and think about where in the World Wide Web I choose to go to today.  That opens up a huge quotient of possibilities even if I keep within my work parameter, which I do.  So I think of some key words that might bring me to a new area that I should be involved in and away I go with just a few key strokes of my handy Google box. It’s better than a magic carpet since I am afraid of heights and I get to stay in my chair with my coffee.

Yesterday I hit up “monetize blogs”, today I went for “blogs press releases” which brought me back in time to June 2005. It’s actually funny to read what some people were saying or predicting what would be happening now.  According to the number of comments and track backs, I guess back in 2005, Steve Rubel predicting that “Blogs are the New Press Release” made people all but freak out.

Steve made some interesting predictions and I wonder if he does have dibs on a real crystal ball because he was dead on about RSS being everywhere by 2007. There were defiantly doubts, I guess, back then, about RSS. I have to admit that if I even knew what an RSS feed was back in 2005 (and I did not) I would also have doubted it’s power but now, reading this, “I’m also not sure whether companies would be willing to trust – hope – that journalists will be sure to hook up their RSS feed, that they will check their RSS reader regularly” is almost hysterical.  Ah, hind sight, I had to control myself not to laugh out loud when one commenter proclaimed, “And in Australia I know of one (count one) major league journalist who uses an RSS aggregator.”  I bet you that number sure has changed. Now it should probably read, “And in Australia I don’t know of one (count one) major league journalist who does not use an RSS aggregator.”

Back in my real chair, in real 2008, I ponder the thoughts of 2005.  No, the press release is not yet dead, but you got to adore some of the mindsets:

  • The only problem that I personally see with that there is still a certain level of uncrediblity with the blog
  • In that sense, blogs and RSS are no different than advertising; companies can use these means to bypass the journalist’s filter and go straight to their ultimate target audience, but that audience knows it’s only getting part of the story.
  • I just think that bloggers are just amateurs, they do their thing with whatever devices are available at the time when the news is happening, it is a 21 century phenomenon, and will never replace real historic journalism.

Now, with all due respect to the posters above, I do believe that the overall thought was that these “amateur, non journalistic blogs” were ones put out BY the corporations.  As if instead of a traditional press release being given out to the news wires, a corporate head would have their own blog and out the information out there. This is supported by quotes like these:

  • If you are keeping just a blog and updating it quite frequently, you will be losing the important blog posts (which are sort of press releases) in the posts clutter. You would have to highlight these important posts separately.
  • From the readers’ point of view, imagine the result of going through hundreds of blogs posts and trying to reach particular important information.

There were also questions referring to the corporate suit not having the time or dedication to updating a blog regularly, more doubts about the quality of writing and the bias of that information.  I guess the real independent, true journalism type blog was still off the radar? Obviously, the importance of blogging was underestimated just as the professionalism that is shown by bloggers was also underestimated.  I can see how the idea of a company generated blog being the only source for a news release would not fly, but that is not at all what the blog has turned out to be.

Now, with the blog fully embraced by the world even the most trusted hallmarks of professional journalism have gotten involved. The New York Times has regular and guest bloggers blogginh about a wide variety of subjects. I have seen well known bloggers as guests on CNN and other news channels where their opinions and expertise are considered invaluable.  What was not seen in 2005 is the importance and trust that America has put into the unbiased, free voice of the average citizen on the other side of a computer monitor nor the power that that voice can wield when influencing popular opinion.  No Blogs have not replaced real historic journalism, but rather have become part and parcel of real historic journalism.

Now we have the desire, rather the real need, of the traditional press release to be released to the blogging community with the hope that it will be picked up and written about. When companies such as Nikon come up with “Blogger Outreach Programs” then it’s pretty obvious that corporate America has figured out that Blogs need to somehow be harnessed and that their placement in the SEO market is greatly assisted by the participation of blogs. And that, of course, brings me back to why Blogg.io is a good idea whose time has come.

I wonder if Steve saw that in his crystal ball.



Ready to Get Started? Have Questions?

NYC 212-929-7716     Kingston, NY 845-383-0890

©2010 DragonSearch

URL for RDF/RSS 1.0 feed http://www.dragonsearchmarketing.com/feed/rdf/ URL for RSS 0.92 feed http://www.dragonsearchmarketing.com/feed/rss/ URL for RSS 2.0 feed http://www.dragonsearchmarketing.com/feed/ URL for Atom feed http://www.dragonsearchmarketing.com/feed/atom/